Special Session 36: Complexity in dynamical systems and applications in biology

Light--scissor--paper: light--mediated intransitivity leads to phytoplankton coexistence

Francesco Paparella
New York University Abu Dhabi
United Arab Emirates
Co-Author(s):    Francesco Paparella (NYUAD); Alessandro Portaluri (UNITO); Xinyue Li (NYUAD)
Abstract:
The paradox of plankton (as stated by Hutchinson in 1961) is usually solved by admitting that coexistence equilibria are indeed unstable, but that instability, rather than leading to the extinction of all but one species competing for a single limiting resource, leads to limit cycles (or chaotic attractors) where several species coexist while their populations fluctuate in time. The cyclical nature of multispecies coexistence (already mathematically proven in 1975 by Leonard and May) has later been rationalized as intransitive competition, that is, the inability of any individual competitor to overcompete all of the others, just as in the game rock-scissor-paper. In this work we show that periodic oscillations of a parameter may induce an intransitive competition dynamics, and thus lead to coexistence in situations where only one species would survive if all parameters were constant in time. Specifically, we consider a plankton model proposed by Huisman and Weissing, and extend it to allow for light dependent growth rates, using the Eilers and Peeters growth-irradiance relationship, with realistic parameters fitted from laboratory experiments. We study the case of a single limiting resource, and we deduce necessary and sufficient conditions for the coexistence of two species. We then extend the discussion to the case of an arbitrary number of species.